Arizona: David

November 23, 2009 - 09:30 am
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Matthew Ladner responds

by David Safier Matthew Ladner commented on the concerns I have expressed, along with others, about the survey Strategic Vision LLC was paid to conduct for G.I. Here are his comments, in full. David- I believed you linked to a...

November 21, 2009 - 11:03 am
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Charter/District budget battle

by David Safier

The Rs planned to cut $144 million in soft capital funding from district schools. The snafu Thursday only delayed the move.

But now some legislators are asking, Why aren't charter schools feeling the budget ax as well?

Here is among the lamest reasons imaginable for not making cuts to charters.

Crandall said after speaking with the governor’s office and House leadership Thursday about the cuts, staff assured him there would be plenty of cuts coming around to all schools.

“They said it was easier to do it this way right now,” he said. “Whoever didn’t get cut now will be cut in January or February.

November 19, 2009 - 11:12 am
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Dem press conference recommends comprehensive budget approach

by David Safier

I happened to be at the Capitol Wednesday, camera and notepad in hand, so I took in the Dem press conference.

The thrust of the conference was to criticize the Rs for their piecemeal approach to budgeting: cut some stuff today and worry everything else some time in the future.

Lujan and Sinema, who spoke and took questions, criticized Brewer for going back on her pledge to protect education from, in the Gov's words, "devastating cuts" by joining with Republican legislators to make, well, devastating cuts to education. They called for Brewer to include Dems in crafting comprehensive budget solutions.

Two D revenue suggestions  struck me as more than reasonable, even to moderate and somewhat-conservative Rs.

November 18, 2009 - 11:35 am
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Charles North, tuition tax credit expert

by David Safier

In the post below, I wrote about the recent meeting of the R-created committee looking into painting a happy face on the tuition tax credit mess. I mentioned it brought in an "expert," Charles North, to explain that tuition tax credits save Arizona millions and millions of tax dollars.

So who is this "expert," Charles North? He's an econ prof from Baylor University. About Baylor, from its website:

Baylor University in Waco, Texas, is a private Baptist university, and a nationally ranked liberal arts institution.

The only publication of note I could find by North is a book he co-authored in 2008: Good Intentions: Nine Hot Button Issues Viewed Through the Eyes of Faith.

November 15, 2009 - 07:56 pm
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Fooled Gold? Another look at the G.I. Civics Test

by David Safier

As you know if you've been reading this blog, I've had several bones to pick with the Goldwater Institute's studies comparing public and private school students in their knowledge of civics, tolerance of others and feelings about the schools they attend. (My criticism of the Civics study is here, and the criticism of the other two are combined in this post.) But here's one objection that never occurred to me until two faithful readers emailed me material that puts the polls themselves into question. (Hat tip to todd and to Eli Blake.)

It's possible the polling company, Strategic Vision LLC, simply made up the numbers in the surveys it gave to Matthew Ladner at G.

November 14, 2009 - 03:17 pm
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Tuition tax credit task force meeting, Part 1

An STO fund sweep? What an idea!

by David Safier

The House task force on tuition tax credits and STOs met Wednesday. This is the House group started by Ds, then joined by some Rs, not to be confused with the Senate committee started by Rs in response to earlier task force.

Both the Republic and the Trib covered the hearing. (If you only read the Star, I don't think you'd have an inkling it happened). My favorite idea that came out of it: If some School Tuition Organizations can't figure out how to give away 90% of the tax credit money that flows in for scholarships, they should return the excess to the general fund.

November 14, 2009 - 11:41 am
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

AP fact checks Palin

by David Safier

It makes me feel slightly dirty giving Sarah Palin any more ink pixels, but reading AP do a take-down on the "facts" in Palin's new book gives me a certain joy, and I want to share it with others. I get the sense the writer had as much fun writing it as I did reading it.

Read it if you're amused by this kind of thing. I know I am.


November 10, 2009 - 04:50 pm
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

For profit colleges need oversight as well

by David Safier

I've been writing about the potential dangers of the profit motive in K-12 schools, because my teaching experience allows me to understand the nature of those schools. I avoid too much discussion of higher ed because I don't know how it works from the inside.

But a few recent articles make the dangers of bottom-line education evident, where putting "asses in classes" is more important than the education provided to the students.

First case in point: At University of Phoenix, Allegations of Enrollment Abuses Persist. The article is about high pressure recruiting of students.

After federal regulators accused the University of Phoenix of systematic enrollment abuses in 2004, the school's parent company paid out nearly $10 million to resolve the allegations.

November 6, 2009 - 09:53 pm
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

"Education Inc., Part III" -- Imagine Schools under the microscope

by David Safier

On Imagine School's website, you can read a list of the corporation's Six Measures of Excellence. Most of them are the usual stuff -- values, achievement, character development -- but one, as the old Sesame Street song says, is not like the others. The final sign of excellence is the development of more and more schools.

New School Development enhances our ability to reach more children, more families, and more communities. As we increase our family of schools, more opportunities abound for Imagine Schools’ educators to grow professionally as well.

Forget their rationalizations about wanting more schools for educational reasons. Like many for profit companies, Imagine needs to grow to survive and prosper.

November 3, 2009 - 05:47 pm
NEWS FEED: Blog for Arizona

Election day diversion: Melvin, "loser-tarians" and nukes

by David Safier

If you haven't voted yet, VOTE! And if friends haven't voted, drag them to the polls.

Meanwhile, on a topic more suitable to the 2010 election a year from now:

Cap'n Al Melvin attended a town hall in Oro Valley October 30, sponsored by Americans for Prosperity and the Goldwater Institute. He praised the sponsors' efforts to rein in state budget spending, then spoke about why things are in the legislative mess they are today. It's because in the state senate, two Republicans are far left, and two others are "loser-tarians." Apparently he got a big laugh from some members of the audience for his little word play.