November 19, 2008 - 14:44

Peace pushes for vote on open primary in 2010

California primary elections may help elect Republicans and Democrats, but they're not all that democratic.

That's the estimation of former state Sen. Steve Peace (D-San Diego), who is pushing for an open primary system through a ballot measure voters could decide on in 2010.

The measure was filed with the state in September, then withdrawn in October after receiving public comments. Peace said that he and other members of the California Independent Voter Project will study the comments and make small changes to the measure before submitting it again.

Peace said the concept is based on an open primary used in Washington known as the "top-two" system, where voters could cast ballots for members of any party in a primary election.

Under the top-two system, the two candidates who receive the most votes in the primary, regardless of party, then advance to the general election. Peace noted that many cities already use such a system in mayoral elections, for example.

"I don't think it changes the outcome, but it changes behavior," Peace said. In primaries now, he said, party nominees are largely chosen by a small, ideologically rigid group of voters because Democrats and Republicans largely don't allow registered voters from other parties to vote in their presidenital primary.

The Democratic and Republican parties do allow decline-to-state voters to cast ballots in some primaries, however.

One observer said there's another advantage to a top-two system: courts have found it constitutional for now.

"The top-two was held up by the Supreme Court as legal, and California's open primary was not," said Douglas Johnson, a fellow at the Rose Institute at Claremont-McKenna College in Los Angeles.

He referred to a "blanket primary" system used in California in the late 1990s that was ultimately thrown out.

When elected officials know they'll be accountable to all voters in a primary election, Peace said, they're more likely to work with politicians in other parties.

"In the primary, the nominees are picked by a plurality," Peace said. "You can't get a democratically elected member in the current system."

 A top-two primary would also give greater say to third-party candidates, Peace said. Right now, such candidates are largely irrelevant in a general election other than to take votes away from a Republican or Democratic candidate, he said.

Using a top-two primary, general elections could conceivably pit a Democrat against a Green party candidate in San Francisco, for example, or a Republican and Libertarian candidate against each other in Orange County, Peace said.

"If the goal for a third party is really into getting involved in public policy, this is a way to do that," he said.

At least one expert on voting systems, however, disputed that third-party candidates would benefit from Peace's proposal.

Richard Winger, publisher of the San Francisco-based Ballot Access News, said that when the "top-two" primary was used in Washington elections this year, not one third-party candidate made the general election ballot.

Further, he said, from 1990 to 2002, Washington used a blanket primary, where all candidates appeared on the same ballot regardless of party during an primary election.

Only once during that stint did a third-party candidate make a general election ballot as a result of the blanket primary, Winger said.

"It's possible, but very unlikely," he said of Peace's belief in more third-party a top-two system, but Peace said they'd be fighting what the country's forefathers envisioned when they set up the United States' early political system.

Until about 150 years ago, Peace said, third-parties would regularly form, make contributions to public debate and even replace one of the major parties of the time - as happened with the Republicans and Whigs.

It's only more recently, he said, that the two major parties have used court decisions to keep third parties from playing a more active role in crafting policy.

"I'm a Democrat, and if we passed this I believe ultimately my party will be better for it," he said.

If government reformers like Peace truly wanted an open primary that both forced changes and passed constitutional muster, Winger said, they'd try an open primary system used in 20 states that allows voters to pick which party's primary ballot they'll vote on, regardless of their own registration.

Another alternative would be elimination of the primary election and institution of a ranked-voting system with instant runoffs, Winger said.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has raised open primaries as a government reform he's hoping to enact, and Peace said he'd welcome the governor's support as part of a bipartisan group backing the measure.

But Peace said he's not overly impressed with the Schwarzenegger-backed reform proposal 11-Proposition 11, which would change how political districts are drawn.

"Candidly, Proposition 11 won't be a big deal one way or another," Peace said. "On the margins, it's kind of an improvement."

Johnson, of the Rose Institute, said voters favor concepts like open primaries and redistricting, but can get confused when such a topic is actually on the ballot.

In reality, he said, redistricting and open primaries have more power together than apart.

"There used to be a fairly numerous bipartisan caucus in the legislature," he said. With those two reforms in place, he said, that could happen again. "You'd see more debate over issues," he added.

Peace said his group is more likely to next take up another topic for possible reform: the state's taxation system.

ELSEWHERE on PolitickerCA.com:

Ben van der Meer is a PolitickerCA.com Senior Reporter and can be reached via email at noreply@politicker.com.

Comments

Your oppinions are very brief


Your oppinions are very brief and pithy,
I tiffany jewelry agree with you. According to the passage you quote, I found that everything can be done if you have confidence in it.

10/14/09 2:33 am

Replica Watches


Cartier Replica Watches Many Replica Gucci well-heeled Chinese shoppers Replica Thomas wylde like Zhao, a film technician Swiss Chanel Ceramic Watches Replica who gets an allowance Replica Bottega Veneta from her parents Replica Prada Handbags Glashutte Fake on top of AH Replica her salary, are spending freely during Replica Watches the global Girard Perregaux Fake Watches economic Audemars Piguet Fake crisis. High-end Replica handbags designers and Jimmy Choo Replica Bags luxury retailers Replica Piaget that Zenith Replica thrive Baume & Mercier Watch Replica on such extravagance hope China s growing luxury-seeking population will cushion TAG Heuer Replica Watch them Bally Handags Replica against Replica Bally the Fake Chopard Watches collapse Fake Tudor in Marc Jacobs Fake Handbags demand in other Louis Vuitton Replica countries.China Breitling Replica Watches s 6 billion Zenith Replica Watches euro ($8 billion) luxury market accounts for just 3 percent Omega Replica Watches of global sales, compared with 38 percent in Europe, 33 percent in South and North Replica Swiss Army America and 12 percent in Japan, according Corum Replica Watches to Bain Replica Ebel Watches & Co. But Fake Longines Watches China Roger Dubuis Fake Watches Wholesale A Lange & Sohne Watch and Brazil Bvlgari Watches are projected Mulberry Replica Handbags to be the two fastest-growing luxury Fake Richard Mille markets Raymond Weil Fake Watches through 2012, according to consulting firm Bain & Co.

09/08/09 9:10 pm

watches


The other day as I talked with a friend I recalled a story Replica Zodiac ecommerce that I heard this summer. Replica Zenith "A compassionate person, seeing a butterfly struggling Replica Vacheron Constantin to free itself from its cocoon, Replica Tissot and wanting to help, very gently loosened the filaments to form an opening. The butterfly was freed, Replica Tag Heuer-
Replica Swiss emerged from the cocoon, and fluttered about but could not fly. Replica Swatch
Replica Skagen What the compassionate person did not know was that only through the birth struggle can the wings grow strong enough for flight. Replica Rolex
Replica Rado Its shortened life was spent on the ground; it never knew freedomReplica Piaget
Replica Patek Philippe never really lived."I call it learning to love with an open hand. It is a learning which has come slowly to me and has been wroughtReplica Panerai
Replica Oris
Replica Omega in the fires of pain and in the waters of patience. Replica Movado
I am learning that I must free the one I love, for if I clutch or cling, try to control, I lose what I try to hold.If I try to change someone I love because I feel I know how that person should be, Replica Mont Blanc
Replica Longines I rob him or her of a precious right, the right to take responsibility for one's own life and choices and way of being. Whenever I impose my wish or want or try to exert power over anotherReplica Jaeger LeCoultre
Replica Jacob & Co I rob him or her of the full realization of growth and maturation. Replica IWC limit and prevent by my act of possession, no matter how kind my intention.I can limit and injure by the kindest acts of protection or concern. Over extended it can say to the other person more eloquently than words, "You are unable to care for yourself; I must take care of you because you are mineReplica Gucci
Replica Givenchy. I am responsible for you."As I learn and practice more and more, Replica Girard PerregauxI can say to the one I love: "I love you, I value you, I respect you and I trust that you have the strength to become all that it is possible for you to become - if I don't get in your way Wow, Replica A Lange & Sohne
I have got to tell everybody that I was pretty apprehensive about receiving Replica Audemars Piguet
another Replica Breitling
Replica Bvlgari cheap replica at www.buy-replicas.com! I just Replica Cartier
received my rolex watches today, Replica Chanel
and it is without a doubt, the best replica Replica Chopard
I ve seen. Clean machining Replica Christian Dior
between Replica Coach
the case Replica Concord
lugs, and a band that is Replica D&G
properly fitted to the Replica Ebel
case were the first two things Replica Fendi
IReplica Franck Muller
inspected upon rolex watch arrival. Highlyluxury watch satisfied with these,

09/08/09 12:00 am

Replica Watches


Omega Replica Watches The Cartier Replica Franck Muller Replica Watches China Replica Rado market Zenith Watch Replica is growing Replica Giverchy Handbags Marc Jacobs Handbags fast. IWC Replica Gucci Fake Beside Replica miu miu Bags Japan Rolex Watch Replica the Jimmy Choo Replica Handbags Rado Watches Replica global Omega Replica Watches downturn, Girard-Perregaux Fake which Zenith Replica Watches Chopard Replica Watches affects Swiss Replica Porsche Design Replica Watches every country, Replica AH China Fake Tag Heuer Watches is quite Porsche Design Replica Baume & Mercier Watch stable, Hamilton Replica Watches Michele Glashutte Watch Replica Norsa, IWC Fake Wholesale Rado Watch chief executive of Daniel Roth Replica Watches Salvatore Replica Emporio Armani Ferragamo SpA, Replica Watches Fake Swiss Army said in Versace Handbags an Franck Muller Replica e-mail Replica Rolex Watch response to Parmigiani Watch Wholesale Michele Watch questions. Replica handbags ""Definitively, Tag Heuer Replica Watches we Fake Richard Mille Bvlgari Watch Replica are Breitling Replica Watches Replica Hublot Watch Concord Fake optimistic.Ferragamo plans to add seven to Replica Mulberry eight Audemars Piguet Watches China stores this Replica Chanel Fake Baume & Mercier Watches year, Breitling Replica Watches Replica Dolce & Gabbana with Cartier Replica Watches Raymond Weil Fake further Richard Mille Replica Watches Michele Watch expansion in Replica Handbags Blancpain Watches Replica Swiss Rolex Replica Watch 2010, according Richard Mille Fake to Gucci Fake Handbags Panerai Watches Norsa.

08/10/09 12:52 am

Tiffany&Co Rose Earrings


Tiffany&Co Rose Earrings ERT049 Online Sale Mont Blanc Rollerball Pen-Starwalker 104226-SN Online Sale Gucci Waist Pouch 28566-8502 Online Sale Mont Blanc Rollerball Pen-Meisterstuck 05833-SN11 Online Sale Mont Blanc Rollerball Pen-Starwalker 08485-SN24 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Griet Black M93555 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Marilyn Limited Edition M40129 GREEN Online Sale Louis Vuitton Cabas GM Blue M95111 Online Sale Tiffany&Co Beaded Bracelet BRT027 Online Sale Tiffany&Co Star Link bracelet BRT086 Online Sale UGG Women's Wallingford ocean blue 5700 OCEAN BLUE Online Sale Tiffany&Co 5 Sevillana Bracelet BRT082 Online Sale Tiffany&Co CONTINUOUS HEART Bracelet BRT026 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Citadin NM M93224 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Sonatine M51902 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Zipped Purse M61727 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Mini Pochette Accessoires M58009 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Pochette Wallet M61726 Online Sale Gucci BI-Fold Wallet 181659-1000 Online Sale Gucci Med. D-Ring Logo and Leather Wallets 138029-9791 Online Sale Gucci Portafoglio Womens Wallet 167468-1000 Online Sale Gucci French Flap Wallet 146199-2019 Online Sale Tiffany&Co Circle Earrings ERT048 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Damier Azur bags On Sale - Cheap Damier Azur online sale Descounted Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Speedy 30 N41531 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Billfold with 6 Credit Card Slots N61666 Online Sale Burberry Women Handbag 13201212-505 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Insolite Wallet M66565 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Brooklyn PM bag N51210 Online Sale Tiffany&Co Eiffel Tower Pendant NET152 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Multipli Cite M51162 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Bastille N45258 Online Sale Tiffany&Co INFINITY CROSS Pendant NET025 Online Sale Louis Vuitton Multiple Bill Holder Damier N60895 Online Sale

08/02/09 9:53 am

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <p> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
9 + 11 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.