November 19, 2008 - 18:02

State Supreme Court agrees to hear petitions seeking to strike down Prop. 8

SAN FRANCISCO - Justices of the California Supreme Court on Wednesday announced they would agree to hear arguments as to why they should strike down Prop. 8, the recently enacted ballot measure that bans gay marriage in the state.

In their order, the high court said that parties involved must prepare arguments and brief answering these three questions:

--Is Prop. 8 invalid because it constitutes a revision of, rather than an amendment to the California Constitution?

--Does Prop. 8 violate the separation of powers doctrine under the California Constitution?

--If Prop. 8 is not unconstitutional, what is the effect, if any, on the marriages of same-sex couples performed before the adoption of Prop. 8?

The court also denied a request by the petitioners - a large group of cities, counties, churches and civil and gay rights organizations to stay or stop the enactment of the measure, meaning that until they issue a ruling the state must continue to disregard same-sex marriages.

San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom praised the court's decision.

"I applaud the Supreme Court's decision to review this important civil rights issue. Every Californian deserves equal protection under the law. I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will affirm that separate is not equal," Newsom said.

Rick Jacobs, founder and chairman of the Courage Campaign, an online progressive issues organization, said Wednesday that his organization will proceed with an ambitious online petition gathering effort to qualify a 2010 ballot measure to reverse Prop. 8.

"While we are confident the court will find in favor of protecting marriage rights for all, we are preparing for any outcome. Our sincere hope is any action the court takes does not negatively affect the thousands of couples who chose to get married before the November election.

"As we await the court's decision, we will work to engage every community in California by mobilizing our members in a grassroots effort to restore marriage rights," Jacobs said in a statement

Meanwhile, Yes on 8/ProtectMarriage.com officials said they too were pleased by the high court's decision.

"This is a great day for the rule of law and the voters of California," said ProtectMarriage.com General Counsel Andy Pugno. "This order means that voters will get their day in court and ensures that voters will have a vigorous defense of Prop. 8 before the California Supreme Court. We are profoundly gratified with the court's order and are confident that Prop. 8 will be upheld."

The petitioners argue that Prop. 8 represents an improper revision rather than an amendment of the California Constitution. To legally revise the constitution requires a three-fourths vote of the state legislature or by convening a state constitutional convention. Constitutional revisions, opponents argue, cannot be made via the ballot box.

Six justices - Chief Justice Ronald M. George, Justice Marvin R. Baxter, Justice Kathryn M. Werdegar, Justice Ming W. Chin, Justice Carlos R. Moreno, and Justice Carol A. Corrigan - signed the court's order, although Justice Moreno indicated that he would grant the requests to stay the operation of Prop. 8 pending the court's resolution of these matters.

Justice Joyce L. Kennard would deny these petitions without prejudice to the filing in the Supreme Court of an appropriate action to determine Proposition 8's effect, if any, on the marriages of same-sex couples performed before Proposition 8's adoption.

In its order, the court said that it would expedite hearing the matter, saying that initial briefs must be filed before Dec. 19 and that oral arguments could be scheduled as early as March 2009.

Jeff Mitchell is a PolitickerCA.com Editor and can be reached via email at noreply@politicker.com.

Comments

cheap software


332efd225 CheapSoftwares.cc is a Online Specialty shop selling great discount oem cheap software

buyCheapSoftware.info is a Land of milk and honey of cheap software buyers.buy cheap software

11/08/09 12:54 am

ugg boots


11/04/09 9:30 am

replica watches


Never over look replica watches the strap of your rolex watch. A good strap of your rolex watches can upgrade your look. It is important to think twice before you tool up Omega Watches. Gold is considerably more expensive than silver. Gold is flaring than silver but it takes a very different attitude to Cartier Watches pull off this kind of Breitling Watches. Be careful when choosing a color that Chanel Watches will perfectly match your usual shoe and/or belt as you should never wrong with a good Tag Heuer leather strap.

10/20/09 2:25 am

replica watches


Check the rolex or replica watches. If there are any rolex watches engravings or imprints Omega Watches, it is a clue that this is not real Breitling Watches. The real Cartier Watches have a smooth case back without any Chanel Watches engravings or other markings, not even with a logo. Moreover, if you can see the inside of the replica watches because it is rolex watches transparent,rolex and you can see-through the case back, it is also fake watches. Real Rolexes do not have any types that reveal the inner side of the watch.

10/07/09 1:49 am

watches


Zodiac ecommerce that I heard this summer. RThe other day as I talked with a friend I recalled

a story Replica eplica Zenith "A compassionate person, seeing a butterfly struggling Replica Vacheron Constantin to free itself from its cocoon, Replica Tissot and wanting to help, very gently loosened the filaments to form an opening. The

butterfly was freed, Replica Tag Heuer-
Replica Swiss emerged from the cocoon, and fluttered about but could not fly. Replica Swatch
Replica Skagen What the compassionate person did not know was that only through the birth

struggle can the wings grow strong enough for flight. Replica Rolex
Replica Rado Its shortened life was spent on the ground; it never knew freedomReplica Piaget
Replica Patek Philippe never really lived."I call it learning to love with an open

hand. It is a learning which has come slowly to me and has been wroughtReplica Panerai
Replica Oris
Replica Omega in the fires of pain and in the waters of patience. Replica Movado
I am learning that I must free the one I love, for if I clutch or cling, try to control, I lose what I try to hold.If I try to change someone I love because

I feel I know how that person should be, Replica Mont Blanc
Replica Longines I rob him or her of a precious right, the right to take responsibility for

one's own life and choices and way of being. Whenever I impose my wish or want or try to exert power over anotherReplica Jaeger LeCoultre


Replica Jacob & Co I rob him or her of the full realization of growth and maturation. Replica IWC limit and prevent by my act of possession, no matter how kind my intention.I can limit

and injure by the kindest acts of protection or concern. Over extended it can say to the other person more eloquently than words, "You are unable to care for

yourself; I must take care of you because you are mineReplica Gucci
Replica Givenchy. I am responsible for you."As I learn and practice more and more, Replica Girard PerregauxI can say to the one I love: "I love you, I value you, I

respect you and I trust that you have the strength to become all that it is possible for you to become - if I don't get in your way Wow, Replica A Lange & Sohne
I have got to tell everybody that I was pretty apprehensive about receiving Replica

Audemars Piguet
another Replica Breitling
Replica Bvlgari cheap replica at! I just Replica Cartier


received my rolex watches today, Replica Chanel
and it is without a doubt, the best replica Replica Chopard
I ve seen. Clean machining Replica Christian Dior
between Replica Coach
the case Replica Concord
lugs, and a band that is Replica D&G
properly fitted to the Replica Ebel
case were the first two things Replica Fendi
IReplica Franck Muller
inspected upon rolex watch arrival. Highlyluxury watch satisfied with

these,

09/08/09 6:31 am

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <p> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
14 + 4 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.