Negative advertisements are a favored subject for righteous indignation among editorial columnists and political pundits. Many assume the ads are used only for baseless smears that distort the record. The overlooked truth, though, is that negative ads can have a dramatic and devastating impact, sometimes against the very candidate who paid for them.
That seems to be the case in Minnesota, where after almost a year of the nastiest, most personal U.S. Senate race in the country, Republican incumbent Norm Coleman announced last week he would unilaterally suspend his negative campaign advertisements for the remainder of the race. The trouble is, it may already have cost him a once-comfortable lead.
Recent polls show Democrat Al Franken, the former Saturday Night Live funnyman who once fronted liberal Air America Radio, leading Coleman by a small margin, thanks largely to an independent electorate divided between the two major party candidates and Independence Party candidate Dean Barkley. And it has been Coleman's favorability ratings that have plummeted, not Franken's, as the senator's negative ads have flourished.
In the latest Minneapolis Star-Tribune poll, just 38 percent of respondents said they had a favorable impression of Coleman's job performance, the lowest he's ever registered in the survey. In May, 45 percent of Minnesota voters though positively of Coleman's job performance. And according to the latest poll, 56 percent call ads run against Franken by Coleman and the National Republican Senatorial Committee unfair attacks; 42 percent say the same thing about ads Democrats are running attacking Coleman.
Some political watchers suggest Minnesota just isn't the place for negative advertising. "In general, Minnesota culture frowns on open conflict, hostility and rudeness, a mindset we call 'Minnesota Nice,'" said Chris Federico, a political scientist at the University of Minnesota. The state's political culture "puts a strong emphasis on clean government and the avoidance of anything that would appear dirty. Negative campaigning runs afoul of both 'Minnesota Nice' and this moralistic attitude toward politics."
While others may disagree that anyone violated the "Minnesota Nice" code, observers do agree that the landscape required drastic measures. With Barack Obama leading the presidential contest in the state and with Democrats funneling millions into two competitive House races there, Coleman's decision may have been made in hopes of casting him in a new and favorable light.
"Coleman realized he had to change the tone of the campaign if he had a chance to be successful," said Blois Olson, a Minnesota political analyst. "He's got so many variables moving against him right now, so he's got to do something fundamentally different."
Attacking Franken, a wealthy comedian prone to dirty jokes who barely lived in Minnesota until deciding to run for the seat, isn't hard. And while last-minute attacks rarely sink in, Olson said Coleman was actually too successful too early. Assaults on Franken's tax records, on a column he wrote for a men's magazine and on myriad tales of crass and inappropriate language used in the pursuit of humor started as early as the spring.
"They got everything about Al Franken out really early. If some of the stuff that they were going to attack Franken on hit him now, it would be a totally different story. It would be game-changing," Olson said. "The negative ads against Franken were running for so long that they had done all the damage they could."
Coleman's attacks focused largely on Franken's personal and business background, tagging him as a tax cheat Hollywood liberal with a dirty mind. Franken's attacks focused more on Coleman's public record, including government oversight, infrastructure and, more recently, the economic bailout proposal, which Franken came out against. "The issues Franken was attacking on were far more relevant," Olson said.
Franken has no intention of pulling down his own ads. "The fact is that there are honest differences between Al Franken and Norm Coleman, and we're going to continue to point out those differences so that voters can see they have a clear choice between change and more of the same," said Colleen Murray, a spokeswoman for the Franken campaign. "It's not time for political stunts to distract from the fact that Norm Coleman has a negative record and his misleading attack ads were backfiring."
Coleman's negative campaign "wasn't getting him anywhere in the numbers. The nastier he got, he kind of looked like McCain did last week: The economy's in the tank, and voters said, 'This isn't what we want to hear about.'"
Indeed, the economic plunge played a major role in the decision to suspend the ads, said Cullen Sheehan, Coleman's campaign manager. "In this environment, in this time when people are nervous and they have a lot of fears, it doesn't help to play into that with negative campaigns," he said. "Part of the decision was that Norm didn't have any interest going back to Washington for six years based on voters thinking he's the lesser of three evils. He wants people to vote for him and not against the other guys."
In general, focusing a campaign on an incumbent's record can be a dangerous way to run a campaign. But this year's Senate race is a unique instance in which a largely positive campaign might have an effect.
Franken's message has largely been one of change, and that's a successful way to urge voters to fire an incumbent. But voters have a third choice, in Barkley, that could cost both candidates. The Independence Party candidate, who served briefly in the Senate after the death of Paul Wellstone in 2006, is pulling almost a third of independent voters to his side, polls show, and about an even number of voters from Coleman and Franken's party bases.
Those who buy into Franken's message that the incumbent should get the boot should be voting for the Democrat. But because of Franken's own baggage, voters who want to vote against Coleman but not for Franken have a happy medium in Barkley. That helps Coleman by depriving Franken of voters who despise Republicans but can't swallow a six-year Franken term, and it helps Franken by depriving Coleman of voters disgusted with the Democrat but less willing to vote Republican.
But just because Coleman isn't running negative ads doesn't mean no one is. The National Republican Senatorial Committee has launched their own barrage of assaults against Franken, including a new one on Tuesday, forcing Coleman to call on the committee he is rumored to have ambitions of running to pull down the ads. "While I can only control those ads that I must personally approve, I am calling on this group to immediately pull down this ad," Coleman said in a statement Tuesday. "I want the people of Minnesota to hear the positive record that we've built together, and the vision of a stronger country, with more jobs, energy independence and quality, affordable health care for all Americans. These negative ads must end."
Because of the third-party ads (Democrats' senatorial committee has been up for months with their own ads hammering Coleman), there is a danger that Coleman could lose credit for his apparently altruistic act. "Nobody distinguishes between the ads you're running and the ads other people are running on your behalf," Olson said. It's something Coleman manager Shaheen acknowledges: "Sometimes that distinction can be difficult, but ultimately we're responsible for the ads that say, 'I'm Norm Coleman and I approve this message,'" he said.
Coleman is currently trailing Franken in the latest Real Clear Politics Average, but no matter the outcome, the race will provide future campaigns with important lessons about negative advertising. The early ads attacking questionable moments in Franken's past were effective, but grew stale over time. And when voter concern focused almost completely on the economy, the attacks provoked a backlash.
Negative advertising remains a tool that can be used to great effect. But if voters begin blaming the candidate running the ad, the opposite effect can devastate a campaign. Coleman backers can only wait to see whether his campaign caught the mistake in time.
Replicas
Replica Wholesale Watches | Fake Luxury Watches | Luxury watches | Replica Wholesale Watches | Fake Luxury Watches | Replica Watches | Replica Watches | Replica Wholesale Watches | Replica Wristwatch | watches brand | Maurice Lacroix Replica Watch | Fake 2009 New Arrival | Replica Louis Vuitton Watch | Fake Longines | Replica Breitling | Breitling Replica Watches | Replica Chanel | Replica Gucci Watches | Replica Patek Philippe | Replica Christian Dior | Hublot Watch | Replica Tudor | Fake Blancpain | IWC Watch | Fake Daniel Roth | Rado Watch Replica | Oris Fake Watches | Hublot Watches Replica | Omega Replica Watch | Louis Vuitton Watches Replica | Corum Replica | Replica Philip Stein Watch | Rolex Replica | Baume & Mercier Replica Watches | Jaeger LeCoultre Replica |
Replica watches | Replica
Replica watches | Replica Breitling Watches | replica soccer jersey | replica soccer jersey | Fake Watches | Fake Alain Silberstein | Bvlgari Watches | Replica Oris Watches | Fake Chopard | Fake Girard Perregaux | Aigner Watch Replica | Replica Dolce & Gabbana Watches | Zenith Replica Watches | Victorinox Swiss Army Replica Watches | Replica Gerald Genta Watch | Glashutte Replica Watch | Cartier Replica Watch | Aigner Watches Replica | Technomarine Replica Watch | Maurice Lacroix Replica | Zenith Watch Replica | Audemars Piguet Watches | Mont Blanc Fake | Jacob & Co Watches | Rado Replica Watch | IWC Watch Replica | Rolex Watches | Baume & Mercier Replica | Oris Replica Watches | Audemars Piguet Fake WatchesReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Replica watches | Replica
Replica watches | Replica Watches | Replica watches | Replica watches | Replica watches | Replica Parmigiani | Replica Louis Vuitton Watches | Replica Alain Silberstein Watches | Panerai Replica Watches | Porsche Design Replica | Cartier Replica Watch | Panerai Watches Replica | Replica Glashutte Watch | Omega Fake | Fake Ulysse Nardin Watches | Louis Vuitton Watches | Alain Silberstein Fake | Replica Vacheron Constantin Watches | Replica Aigner Watches | Longines Replica | Wholesale Hermes Watch | Replica Piaget Watches | Replica Jacob & Co Watches | Victorinox Swiss Army Fake Watches | Replica Daniel Roth | Wholesale IWC Watch | Panerai Replica | Replica Bell & Ross | Fake Franck Muller | Fake Richard MilleReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Fake Cheap Rolex | Fake
Fake Cheap Rolex | Fake Watches | Replica watches | Fake Watches | Replica Watches | Patek Philippe Replica | Bell & Ross Fake | Replica Oris Watches | Rado Watch | Corum Fake Watches | Hamilton Watches Replica | Richard Mille Replica Watches | Wholesale Michele Watch | Victorinox Swiss Army Watches Replica | Aigner Replica Watch | Baume & Mercier Replica Watches | Wholesale Zenith Watch | Parmigiani Watches | Bvlgari Replica | Oris Fake | Chopard Replica | Panerai Watches Replica | Cartier Watches | Aigner Watch | Fake Rado | Breitling Watches | Wholesale Cartier Watch | Zenith Watch Replica | Maurice Lacroix Fake Watches | Fake A Lange & SohneReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Fake Cheap Rolex | Fake
Fake Cheap Rolex | Fake Watches | Replica Cartier | Replica Watches | replica soccer jersey | Baume & Mercier Watch | Replica Emporio Armani Watches | Audemars Piguet Fake | Jacques Lemans Watch Replica | TAG Heuer Watches | Fake Swiss Watches | Wholesale Breitling Watch | Technomarine Fake Watches | Panerai Replica Watch | Replica Dolce & Gabbana Watches | Fake Zenith Watches | Replica Hamilton | Louis Vuitton Watches | Wholesale Glashutte Watch | Replica Parmigiani Watches | Breitling Fake Watches | Fake Louis Vuitton Watches | Replica Dolce & Gabbana Watches | Replica Baume & Mercier Watch | Wholesale Concord Watch | A Lange & Sohne Fake | Replica Bvlgari Watches | Wholesale Vacheron Constantin Watch | Michele Fake Watches | Rolex Replica WatchesReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Largest selection of discount
Largest selection of discount Timberland Boots for sale, Saving a lot at our Timberlands Outlet Store of timberland work boots timberland men boots timberland women boots timberland shoes timberland waterproof boots discount timberlands timberland boots sale cheap timberland boots timberland yellow boots. We assure you of our Best Services at all times.
soccer jersey wholesale |
soccer jersey wholesale | soccer jersey wholesale | soccer jersey wholesale | Replica watches | Fake Watches | Fake Jacques Lemans Watches | Wholesale Baume & Mercier Watch | Tissot Watches Replica | Aigner Replica | watches brand | Jacques Lemans Replica | Roger Dubuis Replica Watches | Glashutte Replica | Replica Piaget Watches | Wholesale Girard Perregaux Watch | Wholesale Ebel Watch | Porsche Design Watches Replica | Oris Watch | Louis Vuitton Watch | Jaeger LeCoultre FakeReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Replica Watches | Replica
Replica Watches | Replica Breitling Watches | Fake Watches | Replica watches | replica soccer jersey | Replica Watches | Fake Cheap Rolex | Vacheron Constantin Fake Watches | Wholesale Official NBA Jersey | Fake Tissot Watch | Replica Christian Dior | Swiss Chanel Ceramic Replica Watch | Porsche Design Watches | Dkny Watch Replica | Replica Porsche Design Watch | Denmark uniform | Louis Vuitton Watches | Swiss Chanel Ceramic Watch Replica | English Jersey | Replica Japan Rolex Watches | Austria Jersey | Wholesale Feyenoord JerseyReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Replica Rolex | Fake Cheap
Replica Rolex | Fake Cheap Rolex | Replica Watches | Fake Watches | Replica watches | Replica Watches | Replica Rolex | Replica Other Watch | Breitling Replica Watch | Boston Celtics Jersey | Fake A Lange & Sohne | Fake Audemars Piguet | Replica Baume & Mercier | Replica Newcastle Jersey | Roma Shirt | Bedat & Co Fake | Fake Girard Perregaux Watches | China uniform | Replica Breitling Watch | Porsche Design Watches | Replica Ulysse Nardin | Fake U-boatReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Fake Cheap Rolex | Replica
Fake Cheap Rolex | Replica watches | Fake Watches | Replica watches | Fake Watches | Replica Omega | Replica Breitling Watches | Fake Piaget Watches | Real Madrid Soccer Jersey | Cheap A.lange Sohne Fake Watch | Replica Titoni | Replica Other Watch | Jaeger Lecoutre Watches Replica | Wholesale Argentinian Jersey | Raymond Weil Watches | Fake Zenith | A.lange Sohne Watch | Replica Chanel Watches | Wholesale Palermo Jersey | Zenith Wristwatch | Fake Alain Silberstein Watches | Villareal JerseyReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
ugg
sound right
Buy uggs?Find ugg ?Where to buy ugg boots in uk?uggs on sale?Uggbootsforsale.co.uk is the specialist online outlet store of ugg bailey butteon ugg boots uk ugg boots for sale Cheap ugg boots Ugg slippers uk Ugg classic cardy Ugg shoes ugg boots UGGS ugg australia ugg boots sale ugg slippers discount uggs free shipping worldwide
Replica watches | Fake
Replica watches | Fake Watches | Replica Omega | Replica Cartier | replica soccer jersey | soccer jersey wholesale | Replica Omega | Burberry Replica Watch | Tissot Watches | Real Madrid Jersey Wholesale | Replica Tudor | Daniel Roth Fake Watches | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Replica Piaget Watches | Breitling Watch | Replica Seiko Watches | Fake Bmw Watches | Replica Chanel | Roma uniform | Wholesale Scottish Jersey | Replica A Lange & Sohne | Replica OtherReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Replica watches | Fake
Replica watches | Fake Watches | replica soccer jersey | Replica Breitling Watches | Replica watches | Replica watches | Replica watches | Cheap Audemars Piguet Watches | Cheap Porsche | Bmw Fake Watch | Cheap Rado Fake Watch | Fake Oris Watch | Vacheron Constantin Fake Watches | Titoni Wristwatch | Rado Watches Replica | Replica Tudor Watch | Hublot Watch | Cheap Baume & Mercier Watches | Cheap Benz Fake Watch | Bmw Watches Replica | Rolex Watches Replica | Tag Heuer WatchReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Replica watches | soccer
Replica watches | soccer jersey wholesale | Replica Cartier | Replica Watches | Replica Omega | Replica Rolex | Replica Cartier | Bell & Ross Watch | Fake Other Watches | Vacheron Constantin Replica | Replica Cartier Watches | Fake Versace Watch | Fake Piaget Watch | Vacheron Constantin Replica Watch | Bell & Ross Watches Replica | Hermes Watches Replica | A.lange Sohne Fake Watch | Fake Louis Vuitton Watches | Cheap Panerai Watches | Cheap Bvlgari Fake Watch | Seiko Replica Watches | Rado Fake WatchesReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
soccer jersey wholesale |
soccer jersey wholesale | Replica Watches | Replica Breitling Watches | soccer jersey supplier | Replica Breitling Watches | soccer jersey supplier | soccer jersey supplier | Replica Versace Watch | Fake Fendi Watches | Cheap Oris Fake Watch | Replica Versace Watches | Cheap Porsche Watches | Hublot Replica | Omega Replica | Fake Corum Watch | Replica Bvlgari Watch | Bell & Ross Replica Watch | Patek Philippe Watches Replica | Replica Panerai Watches | Corum Watches Replica | Cheap Breitling | Replica Louis Vuitton WatchReplica Omega,Replica Breitling Watches,Replica Cartier
Best Watches
Replica Soccer Jersey | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Replica Soccer Jersey | Replica Soccer Jersey | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Replica Soccer Jersey | Replica Soccer Jersey | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Man UTD uniform | France Jersey | Boca Juniors Jersey | Argentinian Jersey | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Replica Palermo Jersey | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Dortmund Jersey Wholesale | Chicago Fire Soccer Jersey | Poland Jersey Wholesale | English Soccer Jersey Wholesale | PSG Jersey Wholesale | Wholesale Croatia Jersey | Wholesale Werder Bremen Jersey | Rangers Jersey | Dutch Soccer Jersey | Replica Chelsea Jersey | English uniform | MLS uniform | River Plate uniform | Portland Trail Shirt | Portland Trail Jersey | New Orleans Hornets Shirt | Official New Jersey Jersey | Detroit Pistons uniform |
Hot Watches
Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Replica Soccer Jersey | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Replica Soccer Jersey | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey Supplier | Soccer Jersey wholesale | Soccer Jersey Supplier | Replica Spain Jersey | Monaco uniform | Atletico Madrid uniform | Barcelona uniform | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Ukraine Shirt | Chelsea Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Villareal Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Wholesale Argentina Jersey | Soccer Jersey Wholesale | Wolfsburg Soccer Jersey | Wholesale Newcastle Jersey | Ajax uniform | AC milan Soccer Jersey Wholesale | France Jersey | Replica Argentina Jersey | Replica Seville Jersey | Replica Atletico Madrid Jersey | San Antonio Spurs Shirt | Official Toronto Raptors Jersey | Wholesale Chicago Bulls Jersey | Phoenix Suns Shirt | Utah Jazz Shirt |
Fashion Watches
Fake Watches | Watches Wholesale | Replica Wristwatch | Fake Watches | Watches Wholesale | watches brand | Replica Watches | watches brand | Replica Wholesale Watches | watches brand | Chanel Watch | Replica Bedat & Co | Fake Bvlgari | Fake Audemars Piguet Watches | Panerai Replica Watch | Parmigiani Watches | Tissot Replica Watch | Replica Longines Watch | Replica Chopard Watches | Rolex Ladies Replica Watch | Breguet Fake | Replica Gucci Watches | Replica Swiss Rolex | Vacheron Constantin Fake | Replica Swiss Chanel Ceramic | Replica Corum | Fake Christian Dior Watches | Breguet Replica | Swiss Rolex Watches Replica | Rado Watch Replica | Guess Fake Watches | Fake Patek Philippe | Zenith Fake Watches | Concord Replica Watch | Vacheron Constantin Replica Watches |
Replica Watches
Replica Watches,Replica Handbags,Replica Shoes,pens Discount. Many Fake Baume & Mercier Watches well-heeled Replica Watches Chinese Replica Handbags Wholesale shoppers like Zhao, a film technician who gets Fendi Replica Bags an allowance from Mulberry Fake Handbags her parents on top of Swiss Chanel Ceramic Watches Replica her salary, are Replica Wholesale handbags spending freely Fake Ebel Watches during the global economic crisis. High-end designers and luxury retailers Jaeger LeCoultre Watches Replica that Louis Vuitton Handags Replica Replica Louis Vuitton Watch thrive Replica Bvlgari Watches on such extravagance hope China s growing luxury-seeking population will cushion them against Replica Designer handbags the collapse in Christian Dior Replica Handbags demand in Marc Jacobs Replica Bags other countries.China s 6 Replica Movado billion euro ($8 billion) Gerald Genta Watches luxury Wholesale Swiss Rolex Watch market Swiss Army Fake Watches accounts for just 3 percent of global sales, Fake Rado Watches compared with 38 percent in Europe, Piaget Replica Watch IWC Watch Replica 33 Chanel Replica Bags percent in Replica Handbags South Wholesale Jacob & Co. Watch and Replica Watches North America Replica Handbags and Chopard Watch 12 percent in Japan, Hermes Handags Replica according 2009 New Arrival Watches Replica to Bain Wholesale Replica Handbags Wholesale IWC Watch & Co. But China Fake Marni Handbags and Brazil are projected to be Replica Thomas Wylde the Replica Swiss Watches two fastest-growing luxury markets through 2012, Omega Replica Watches according to consulting firm Breitling Replica Watch Bain & Replica Marc Jacobs Co.
Replica Watches
Replica Handbags:Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags,Discount Fake Handbags Purses took the red-carpet Coach Replica Bags by Rado Watches Replica storm, Replica Handbags one-upping Replica Ulysse Nardin each Fake Tissot Watches other with each Versace Handbags step of the Replica Mulberry Gucc Replica Bags Metropolitan AH Handags Replica s infamous Replica Miu Miu Handbags staircase. While Jessica Szohr Miu Miu Replica Bags initially Louis Vuitton Handags Replica wowed the Swiss Rolex Watch Replica crowds with her sophisticated strapless black Bally Replica Christian Replica Wholesale Handbags Dior gown Replica Handbags and Replica Watches pulled back pony-tail, IWC Replica Watches seconds Corum Replica Watch later Leighton Replica Wholesale handbags Meester stole the spotlight with her paisley Gucc Replica print Louis Vuitton look and Replica Handbags new light locks. But Hermes Replica perhaps it was Replica AH Blake Replica Juicy Couture Bags Lively, Concord Fake the last to arrive, Chanel Handbags who really made jaws drop with Mulberry Fake Handbags her Giverchy Replica Audemars Piguet Fake showy teal Versace Replica Watches number Replica Ulysse Nardin Watches and slicked back up-do. But what Fake Gucc Handbags do Giverchy Replica Handbags you Replica Watches Miu Miu Replica Yves Saint Laurent Replica think? Which of Replica Oris Watch these starlets wore it better?
Post new comment