October 30, 2008 - 17:39

After Obama, McCain rulings, state rep. wants presidential candidates to prove citizenship, place of birth

A week after a Pennsylvania lawsuit challenging Barack Obama's right to run for president was thrown out of court, a state lawmaker has authored a bill that would force presidential candidates to prove they're a United States citizen before being placed on state ballots.

"As a veteran and an elected official who takes an oath of office, just like every past and future President of the United States, to uphold and defend the Constitutional rights of the citizens I represent, it is greatly perplexing and beyond troubling that a political candidate can ascend to the White House without providing sufficient documentation verifying his or her place of birth or American citizenship," state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe (R-Butler County) said in a statement. "This legislation is intended to send the message that even those candidates who are running for our nation's highest office are not above the law."

Former Chairman of the Montgomery County Democratic Committee Philip Berg filed the suit against Obama, saying the candidate did not provide an authentic birth certificate. The judge ruled against him, saying harm from an allegedly ineligible candidate was "too vague and its effects too attenuated to confer standing on any and all voters."

In an interview with PolitickerPA.com, Metcalfe said many of his constituents came to his office asking him about the validity of the lawsuit against Obama. When he and his staff researched the issue, Metcalfe said they were shocked to find out presidential candidates in Pennsylvania don't have to prove that they were born in the United States, or that they are a citizen.

Every other elected office in the state must provide proof they are eligible to run, he said.

"I think the majority of citizens would be shocked there isn't more oversight of candidates by state government," Metcalfe said.

The lawmaker argues he is only trying to close a loophole that will put voters' minds at ease about the candidates on the ballot. Even with the intense scrutiny a presidential candidate must endure, the state must have a system of checks and balances, he said.

"It would really be the greatest hoax in U.S. history if somebody did get past the scrutiny," he said.

Still, it's almost impossible to separate his stated intention and the questions some Republicans have about Obama's origins. Rumors have spread that Obama was actually born outside the country and that his birth certificate is a fake. That birth certificate proves he was born in Hawaii in 1961.

Asked if he thinks the Democratic presidential nominee was born in the United States and is a citizen, Metcalfe didn't equivocally answer "yes."

"You would certainly think someone is, having held office as a state senator and U.S. senator," Metcalfe said. "I think every American would think that.

"This has not been a question I've been involved in trying to investigate, as far as where he was born," he added.

Metcalfe also said his bill will obviously not take effect by Nov. 4.

John McCain's right to run for president has also been challenged by some. The Republican presidential nominee has born in the Panama Canal Zone while his father was stationed there with the U.S. Navy.

A U.S. District Judge in California in September threw out a similar lawsuit against McCain, saying both his parents were U.S. citizens and recognizing a law passed a year after McCain's birth retroactively making those born in the zone "natural-born citizens."

Metcalfe is at times a controversial figure in the Pennsylvania General Assembly. During the summer he opposed a state House resolution that would have sponsored a Muslim's group's convention in Philadelphia.

His high-profile stances on positions like abortion, immigration and marriage have prompted his opponent in the 12th Legislative District to accuse him of not focusing enough on local issues.

 

Alex Roarty is a PolitickerPA.com Reporter and can be reached via email at noreply@politicker.com.

Comments

Thank you for providing us


Thank you for providing us these tiffany jewelry
suggetions which are such useful tool to deal with some difficult problems.I really appreaciate of it.

10/14/09 8:52 pm

Replica Watches


Replica Watches,Replica Handbags,Replica Shoes,pens Discount. took prada Handags Replica Replica Audemars Piguet Watch the Replica Bvlgari Watches red-carpet by Omega Fake storm, one-upping each other with each step of Replica Bedat & CO the Bally Fake Handbags Metropolitan Fake Bottega Veneta Handbags s Replica Watches infamous Corum Replica TAG Heuer Watches staircase. While Movado Replica Watches Jessica Szohr initially wowed the Swiss Army Fake Watches Wholesale Chopard Watch crowds with Replica Watches Raymond Weil Watches her sophisticated jewelry wholesale Christian Dior Replica Watches strapless Christian Dior Watch Replica Replica 2009 New Arrival Watches black Replica Handbags Fake Swiss Rolex Christian Fake IWC Watches Dior Breitling Replica Watches gown and pulled back pony-tail, Chanel Watch Replica Longines Replica seconds later Leighton Meester stole the spotlight Omega Fake Watches with her Dolce & Gabbana Replica Movado Replica Watch paisley print Replica Panerai Watch Louis Breitling Replica Watches Vuitton look Wholesale Audemars Piguet Watch and new light Mulberry Handbags locks. But Roger Dubuis Watches Replica perhaps Replica handbags Replica Loewe it Chloe Fake Handbags was Blake Lively, the last to Porsche Design Watch Replica arrive, Fake Hamilton who Tag Heuer Watches Replica really Fake Ulysse Nardin made Thomas wylde Fake Handbags jaws Gucci Watches drop Rolex Fake Watches with Gerald Genta Fake Corum Replica Watches Ulysse Nardin Watch her Swiss Chanel Ceramic Watches Replica Michele Replica showy teal Versace number and slicked Louis Vuitton Watches back up-do. Wallet Replica Handbags Gucci Watches But Zenith Replica Watches what Jaeger LeCoultre Replica Watches do Replica Cartier Watch Replica IWC you think? Which Parmigiani Fake of these starlets Balenciage Replica Japan Rolex Watch wore it better?

08/10/09 1:21 pm

Replica Watches


Wholesale Replica handbags And Purse - Discount Designer Handbags Purse - High Quality Bags The China market is Oris Watch Replica growing fast. Beside the global Bally Handbags downturn, which affects Mulberry Replica Bags Juicy Couture Replica every country, China is Replica Louis Vuitton Handbags quite Fendi Fake Handbags stable, Michele Fake Yves Saint Laurent Handbags Norsa, chief Marc Jacobs Replica executive Dolce & Gabbana Replica Bags of Replica Piaget Watch Salvatore Ferragamo Replica Handbags SpA, said Wholesale Oris Watch in an e-mail response Christian Dior Replica Bags to questions. Replica Chloe Bags ""Definitively, we are optimistic.China Replica Dolce & Gabbana s 6 Miu Miu Fake Handbags billion Louis Vuitton Replica Watches euro ($8 billion) luxury market accounts Replica Thomas Wylde Handbags Wholesale Tag Heuer Watch for Omgea Fake just 3 percent of Mulberry Replica Bags global Replica Watches sales, compared Replica HandBags Designer with Replica Watches 38 percent in Europe, 33 percent Jimmy Choo Replica Handbags Replica Blancpain Watches in Replica Handbags South and North Jaeger LeCoultre Fake Watches America Fake Thomas wylde Handbags and 12 Movado Replica Watch percent Thomas Wylde Replica Bags in Replica Wholesale handbags Japan, according to Bain Replica Watches Fake Audemars Piguet & Co. But China and Balenciaga Replica Bags Brazil Giverchy Replica are projected to Replica Handbags be the two fastest-growing luxury markets through 2012, according to consulting firm Mulberry Handbags Bain & Co.

07/09/09 3:13 am

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <p> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
10 + 5 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.